DG Competition
Office of Fair Trading

Legislation
Treaty of Rome
>Art 81
>Art 82

Commission Regulation (EC) No 772/2004

Council Regulation 1/2003
 

 


 

EC Competition Law

Technology Transfer Regulation

John Lambert

20 Dec 2005

The Technology Transfer Block Exemption (Commission Regulation (EC) No 772/2004 of 27 April 2004 on the application of Article 81(3) of the Treaty to categories of technology transfer agreements) automatically exempts from art 81 (1) of the Treaty of Rome technology transfer agreements entered into between two undertakings permitting the production of contract products. This regulation came into force on 1 May 2004 and will subsist until 30 April 2014. It replaces Regulation (EC) No 240/96, the previous technology block exemption, which it repeals

Scope

The exemption applies to the extent that such agreements contain restrictions of competition falling within the scope of art 81(1). It shall apply for as long as the  intellectual property right in the licensed technology has not expired, lapsed or been declared invalid. In the case of know-how, the exemption will subsist for as long as the know-how remains secret, except in the event where the know-how becomes publicly known as a result of action by the licensee, in which case the exemption shall apply for the duration of the agreement.

Market Share Thresholds

The above exemption shall apply on condition that the market share of each of the
parties does not exceed 30 % on the affected relevant technology and product market unless the parties are connected in which case the threshold drops to 20%.

Exclusions from the Exemption in the Case of Competing Undertakings

An agreement between competing undertakings cannot be exempted if it has as its  object:

bullet

the restriction of a party's ability to determine its prices when selling products to third parties;

bullet

the limitation of output, except limitations on the output of contract products imposed on the licensee in a non-reciprocal agreement or imposed on only one of the licensees in a reciprocal agreement;

bullet

the allocation of markets or customers except:
(i) the obligation on the licensee or licensees to produce with the licensed technology only within one or more technical fields of use or one or more product markets,
(ii) the obligation on the licensor and/or the licensee, in a non-reciprocal  agreement, not to produce with the licensed technology within one or more technical fields of use or one or more product markets or one or more exclusive territories reserved for the other party,
(iii) the obligation on the licensor not to license the technology to another licensee in a particular territory,
(iv) the restriction, in a non-reciprocal agreement, of active and/or passive sales by the licensee and/or the licensor into the exclusive territory or to the exclusive
customer group reserved for the other party,
(v) the restriction, in a non-reciprocal agreement, of active sales by the licensee into the exclusive territory or to the exclusive customer group allocated by the
licensor to another licensee provided the latter was not a competing undertaking of the licensor at the time of the conclusion of its own licence,
(vi) the obligation on the licensee to produce the contract products only for its own use provided that the licensee is not restricted in selling the contract
products actively and passively as spare parts for its own products,
(vii) the obligation on the licensee, in a non-reciprocal agreement, to produce the contract products only for a particular customer, where the licence was granted in order to create an alternative source of supply for that customer; or

bullet

the restriction of the licensee's ability to exploit its own technology or the restriction of the ability of any of the parties to the agreement to carry out research and development, unless such latter restriction is indispensable to
prevent the disclosure of the licensed know-how to third parties.

Exclusions in the Case of Non-competing Undertakings

An agreement between non-competing undertakings cannot be exempted if it has as its object:

bullet

the restriction of a party's ability to determine its prices when selling products to third parties save that this provision does not rule out the possibility of imposing a maximum sale price or recommending a sale price that does not amount to a fixed or minimum sale price as a result of pressure from, or incentives offered by, any of the parties;

bullet

the restriction of the territory into which, or of the customers to whom, the licensee may passively sell the contract products, except:
(i) the restriction of passive sales into an exclusive territory or to an exclusive customer group reserved for the licensor,
(ii) the restriction of passive sales into an exclusive territory or to an exclusive customer group allocated by the licensor to another licensee during the first two
years that this other licensee is selling the contract products in that territory or to that customer group,
(iii) the obligation to produce the contract products only for its own use provided that the licensee is not restricted in selling the contract products actively and
passively as spare parts for its own products,
(iv) the obligation to produce the contract products only for a particular customer, where the licence was granted in order to create an alternative source of
supply for that customer,
(v) the restriction of sales to end-users by a licensee operating at the wholesale level of trade,
(vi) the restriction of sales to unauthorised distributors by the members of a selective distribution system; or

bullet

the restriction of active or passive sales to end-users by a licensee which is a member of a selective distribution system and which operates at the retail level, without prejudice to the possibility of prohibiting a member of the system from operating out of an unauthorized place of establishment.

The above provisions shall continue to apply where the parties to the agreement are not competing undertakings when the agreement is entered but later become competing undertakings afterward unless the agreement is subsequently amended in any material respect.

Excluded Restrictions

The exemption shall not apply to any of the following obligations:

bullet

any direct or indirect obligation on the licensee to grant an exclusive licence to the licensor or to a third party designated by the licensor in respect of its own severable improvements to or its own new applications of the licensed technology;

bullet

any direct or indirect obligation on the licensee to assign, in whole or in part, to the licensor or to a third party designated by the licensor, rights to its own severable improvements to or its own new applications of the licensed technology;

bullet

any direct or indirect obligation on the licensee not to challenge the validity of intellectual property rights which the licensor holds in the common market, without prejudice to the possibility of providing for termination of the technology
transfer agreement in the event that the licensee challenges the validity of one or more of the licensed intellectual property rights.

Furthermore, where the undertakings party to the agreement are not competing undertakings, the exemption shall not apply to any direct or indirect obligation limiting
the licensee's ability to exploit its own technology or limiting the ability of any of the parties to the agreement to carry out research and development, unless such latter restriction is indispensable to prevent the disclosure of the licensed know-how to
third parties.

Withdrawal

The Commission may withdraw the benefit of the regulation where it finds in any particular case that a technology transfer agreement to which the exemption applies nevertheless has effects which are incompatible with art 81(3). National competition authorities have a corresponding power within their respective territories.

 

 


HomeCultureBrandsDesignTechnologyIndustriesSite IndexContact

                   
                   

Important